CareerUpdated Jan 2026

Should I Accept a Counteroffer? A Values-Based Decision Framework

Receiving a counteroffer triggers emotional whiplash. Just when you'd steeled yourself to leave, your employer suddenly offers what you'd wanted all along. It feels validating, but also raises questions: Why did it take a resignation to get their attention? Can you trust that things will actually change?

Key Takeaway

This decision is fundamentally about Financial Gain vs. Job Security. Your choice will also impact your professional relationships.

The Core Values at Stake

This decision touches on several fundamental values that may be in tension with each other:

Financial Gain

The immediate financial benefit of the counteroffer. Consider whether money alone addresses your reasons for leaving.

Job Security

Your sense of stability in your current role. Evaluate whether accepting might actually decrease your long-term security.

Professional Relationships

Your connections and reputation at both companies. Consider how accepting or declining affects these relationships.

Career Growth

Your trajectory and development opportunities. Assess whether the counteroffer truly improves your growth prospects.

Trust and Respect

The foundation of your relationship with your employer. Consider whether trust can be maintained after this situation.

5 Key Questions to Ask Yourself

Before making this decision, work through these questions honestly:

  1. 1Why did I start looking for a new job in the first place—does the counteroffer address those reasons?
  2. 2If my employer valued me this much, why did it take a resignation to prove it?
  3. 3Will my loyalty be questioned going forward, and how might that affect my career here?
  4. 4Is the new opportunity genuinely better, or am I just avoiding the discomfort of change?
  5. 5What does my gut say when I imagine staying vs. leaving in 6 months?

Key Considerations

As you weigh this decision, keep these important factors in mind:

Whether the counteroffer addresses your original reasons for leaving
Statistics showing 50-80% of counteroffer acceptors leave within 18 months
Potential damage to your professional reputation at both companies
Whether trust has been fundamentally broken
If the counteroffer is just money vs. addressing systemic issues
Your relationship with your manager and their advocacy
The rarity of genuine counteroffers that represent real change

Watch Out For: Status Quo Bias

Humans naturally prefer avoiding change, even when change would benefit them. A counteroffer makes staying feel like the 'safe' choice, but the underlying problems that made you want to leave likely remain. The familiar feels safer, but familiar problems are still problems.

Make This Decision With Clarity

Don't just guess. Use Dcider to calculate your alignment score and make decisions that truly reflect your values.

Download on the App Store

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do experts say never to accept a counteroffer?
Statistics show most counteroffer acceptors leave within 18 months anyway. The underlying issues rarely get solved. Trust is often damaged on both sides. The company may be buying time to replace you. Your new potential employer's bridge is burned. The reasons you wanted to leave don't disappear with a raise.
What percentage of people who accept counteroffers leave anyway?
Studies suggest 50-80% of employees who accept counteroffers leave within 12-18 months, either voluntarily or involuntarily. The reasons they wanted to leave persist, trust erodes, and they often feel they 'missed their chance' at the opportunity they turned down.
When is it okay to accept a counteroffer?
Rare exceptions exist when: your only reason for leaving was compensation and it's now fixed, you have exceptional trust with your employer, the counteroffer includes genuine structural changes (new role, new team), or you were using the other offer only as leverage (risky). These situations are uncommon.
How do I decline a counteroffer professionally?
Express gratitude for the offer and your time at the company. Be firm in your decision without extensive justification. Say something like: 'I truly appreciate this offer and my time here. After careful consideration, I've decided to proceed with my resignation. I want to ensure a smooth transition.' Keep it brief and professional.
Will accepting a counteroffer hurt my reputation?
Potentially, in both directions. The company you're turning down may see you as unreliable—that bridge is likely burned. Internally, you may be viewed as a flight risk, passed over for promotions, or first on the list during layoffs. Your manager might privately resent being forced to act. These risks are real.

Related Decisions

Should I Quit My Job?

The thought of quitting your job often comes with a mix of excitement and dread. You might feel trapped between the security of your current position and the pull of something better, leaving you paralyzed by uncertainty about whether leaving is brave or reckless.

Should I Accept a Promotion?

Being offered a promotion triggers a complex emotional response—flattery, pressure, excitement, and anxiety all at once. You might feel obligated to say yes because it's what you're 'supposed' to want, even as doubts whisper about longer hours, new stresses, or leaving work you actually enjoy.

Should I Relocate for a Job?

A job offer in another city forces you to weigh competing priorities. The career opportunity might be exceptional, but uprooting your life—leaving friends, family, and familiar surroundings—feels daunting. You're trying to decide if this is the chance of a lifetime or a disruption you'll regret.

People Also Considered

Similar decisions in other areas of life:

Buy or Rent a HomeMove to a New CityEnd a Relationship

Sources

  • Capelli, P. (2000). A Market-Driven Approach to Retaining Talent. Harvard Business Review.
  • Hom, P. W., & Griffeth, R. W. (1995). Employee Turnover. South-Western College Publishing.
← More Career decisions|All decision guides